The Curse of Salvation

The Curse of Salvation

Friday, 13 January 2023

“THIS IS THE YEAR OF POLITICAL REFORM, IT IS THE YEAR OF DEMOCRACY”.

The  above  quoted  words  were  pronounced  by ACT-WAZALENDO  national  leader   Zito  Kabwe,   in  his  positive  response  to  President  Samia  Suluhu  Hassan’s  decision  to  lift  the  ban  on  political  rallies;  and   to  resume  the   the  stalled   ‘constitution  review’  process;  plus  her  promise  to  have  various  obnoxious  laws  reviewed.   That  will  be   the  subject  of  today’s  presentation.  But   before   we  get  there,  we   wish  first  to  give  due  recognition  to  the  special  political  significance  of  this   particular  day,  12th  January,  2023,  which   is  Zanzibar’s   ‘Mapinduzi  Day’;   that   marks  the  59th  anniversary  of  that   glorious  Revolution   which  overthrew  Sultan  Jamshid  Abdulla’s  Arab  minority  government.                                                     
             We   thus   joyfully   join   our  Zanzibar  brethren   in  celebrating  this  great  day  in  the  political  history  of  Zanzibar.    And,   indeed,   “all  men  and  women    of  good  will”   will  similarly   be  joining   the  President  and  the  people  of  Zanzibar  in  celebrating  this  auspicious  occasion.
        For  the  benefit  of  our  younger  generation,  it  may  be  helpful  to  briefly   narrate  the  story  behind   this  revolution,  especially  the  reason  why  it  happened.   The  relevant  background  is  that  the  Zanzibar  State   had   an  unfortunate  long  history,  of  conflict  laden,  plus post-election  violence;  starting  right   from  the  first  general  election   which  was  held  there  in  July  1957; in  which  the  Arab  Zanzibar  Nationalist  Party   lost  dismally.                                                                                                        The  annual  report  of  the  colonial  Provincial  Administration  for  the  year  1958,   states  that  “the  year  (1957)  was  notable  for  the  extent  to  which  ‘hate  politics’  infested  almost  every  sector  of  life  in  Zanzibar.   Traders,   cultivators,  labourers,   fishermen,  and  even  housewives,  were  all  affected. Funerals   and   religious  functions  were  boycotted  by  rival  political  groups.   Women  even  pawned  their  clothes  in  order  to raise  funds  for  the  Bus  fare  to  political  meetings! Such  were   the  immediate  results  of  the first  common  roll  elections  for  these  formerly  peaceful  Islands”.  
        Thereafter,   every subsequent  general elections was  similarly   marred  by   endless  conflicts  and  violence,   caused  principally  by   the  colonial  Administration’s  unfair  practice  of  gerrymandering  the  constituency  boundaries  in  favour  of  the  Arab  political  parties.   This  was  particularly  apparent  in  the  pre-independence  general  election  of  July,  1963.    It   is  on  record  that  Sir  George  Mooring,  the  last  official   “British  Resident”  in  Zanzibar,  as  well  as  Mwalimu  Julius  Nyerere,  the  President  of  Tanganyika;   both  warned  the  British  government  against  granting  independence  in  such  controversial  circumstances;  but  this  warning  was  ignored;  and  the  British   just  went  ahead  and  granted  the  instruments  of  Independence  to  Sultan  Jamshid  Abdulla,  at  midnight  on  9/10th    December,  1963.                                                                                          
        As   far  as  the  Afro-Shirazi  Party  was  concerned,  this  was  the  “last  straw  that  broke  the  camel’s  back”;   and   active  secret  preparations  for  the  overthrow  of  the  Sultan’s  government,  commenced  soon  thereafter.  
In  the  matter  of   political  reform.
 “Political   leaders  hail  political  rebuilding”;  so  said  the  Daily  News  of  Wednesday,  January  4th,  2023  on  its  front  page,   and  continued  thus :  “political  leaders  have  welcomed  President  Dr.  Samia’s  decision  to  lift  the  ban  on  political  rallies,  saying  that  the  move  is  crucial  in  building  democracy  for  sustainable  development.  They   also  hailed   President  Samia’s  commitment  to  revive  the  constitutional  review  process,  as  well  as  amending   various  laws”.                                                        
        This  will  be  our  main  topic  for  discussion  in  this  presentation;   but  we  will  focus  primarily  on  the  specific  matter  of  reviving  the  stalled  constitutional  review  process.
President   Samia  said  the  following,  in   her   powerful   speech  delivered  on  that  occasion:- “We  have  been  brainstorming  on  this  matter  for  a  long  time  now.  Some   stakeholders  have  proposed  that    we  should  start  with  the  Warioba  draft;  while  others  are  of  the  view  that  since   the  Warioba   draft   was  crafted  eight  years  ago,  many   things  have  changed  in  the  meantime;  which  makes  it  necessary  to  look  at the  current  situation  and  proceed  from  there.                                     
            Hence,   the  crucial   question  that  seeks to  be answered  is  this : What  then,  should  be  our  starting  point?  A country’s  constitution  is  commonly  defined  as  “the  basic,  or  fundamental  law  of  the  country, which  lays  down  its  Executive,  Legislative,  and  Judicial  Institutions;  and  describes   the  functions  of  each  of  these institutions,  as  well  their  powers  and  relations  between  them; It   provides  for  the  distribution  of  powers  among  them,  and  the  relations between  them.
        It  is  my  contention  that  the  current  (1977)  constitution  of  the  United  Republic,  fits  exactly into this  definition;  for  it  makes   appropriate  provision  for  the  establishment  of  these  institutions  of  State  governance;  plus providing  for  other  essential  matters,  specifically,  the  fundamental  principles  and  objectives  of  State  policy;    the  basic  rights  and  duties  of  the  country’s  citizens;  the  provisions  for  State  financing;  and    for  the  establishment  of  the  country’s  Armed  Forces.     
        But  apart  from  that,   there  are  the  established  “constitutional   principles”,  which  have  guided  all  our  past  constitution-making  processes,  starting  with  the  Tanganyika  Republican  constitution  of  1962  onwards.    Basically,   these   are  the  principles  of  democracy;  and  of  the  ethics  and  integrity  for  the   people’s   chosen  leaders.   Thus:-                       
*the   constitution  must  recognize  the  fundamental  equality  of  all  human  beings,  and  the  right  of  every  individual  to  dignity  and  respect.                                                                                Consequently,   the  constitution  must  ensure  that:-                             * there  shall  be  maximum  political  freedom  for all  the citizens,  within  the  confines  of  the  law;  * there  shall  be  maximum  possible  participation  by  the  citizens  in  their  own  government,  and  ultimate control  by   them.                                                             *there shall  be  complete  freedom  for  the  citizens  to choose  their  representatives  on  all  the   Legislative  Organs.                        *the   fundamental  rights   and  duties  of  every  citizen;  as  well  as  the  principles  of  good  governance, especially  the  rule  of  law,  are  duly  observed.
            It  was  intended  that  all  of  these  principles  will  be  duly  incorporated  in  our  current  constitution,  but,  alas,  other  considerations  led  the  constitution  makers  to  make  some  obvious   mistakes,  for  example   by  failing  to  allow  the  participation  of  ‘private  candidates’   in  all  our  elections;  by  including  a  provision  which   stipulated  that  “in  order  to  qualify  for  election,  a  candidate  must  belong  to  a  registered  political  party,  and  his/her  candidature  must  be  sponsored  by  such  political  party”.                                                                       
           This   constitutional   provision   has   generated considerable  debate  and  criticism   among  stakeholders,   who  rightly feel  that    this   is  a  beach  of  the people’s  fundamental  right  “to  freely  participate  in  their  own  government”. I   have   myself contributed  to  the  weak   defense  of  this  provision,  by  relying wholly  on  the  doctrine  which  presents  the  role  of   elections as   that  of  “building  majorities  of  relatively  like-minded  persons  in  the  Legislature,  in order  to  facilitate  the  decision-making  processes  therein.  Mea  culpa.
        However,  as  the  Holy  Bible  says  in  Ecclesiastes,  3; 1-8:   “to  everything  there  is  a  season;  and  a    time  for  every  purpose  under  the  heaven”.  At   the  time  when  we  were  tasked  to  prepare  proposals  for  the  current  1977  constitution,   our  country  was  operating  under  the  “One-party  constitution  political  dispensation.   We   were  thus   obliged  to  take  into  account  the  needs  and   requirements  of  that   time.             
            But all   that   notwithstanding,  I  feel   must   personally   confess, and  beg  for  forgiveness,  for  my  complicity  in  this   constitutional   ‘malpractice’.  For  I  was  the  Secretary  to  the  20-man  commission,  which  was  tasked  by  CCM,  to prepare  the   proposals  for  this  constitution.  And   In  that  capacity,  I  was  the  initiator  of  the  recommendations   for   all   the  proposals,  which  were  then  submitted  to  the  said  commission  for  consideration  and  approval. I  can  therefore  disclose  the  principal  reason   which  accounts  for  this  apparent  constitutional   ‘malpractice’.
            In   that connection,   I  will  refer  to  the  clear  warning   that   is  embedded   in  President   powerful  speech,  namely  that  “the  desired   constitution  must  be  Tanzania’s  mother  law,  something  suitable  for  all  Tanzanians;  and  not  a  political  party’s  constitution”.                                                                                    There   is  no  denying   the  fact  that  some  of  the  contents  of  the  current  constitution,  were   indeed  dictated  by  CCM,  the  ruling  party;   and  specifically,  the  provision  regarding   the  ‘two-government’   structure  of  the  Union.    And   I  have  humbly  admitted  that  fact   in Chapter Seven  of   my  book  titled  “Historia  ya  Muungano  wa  Tanganyika  na  Zanzibar” (Tanzania  Educational  Publishers   Ltd,  Bukoba,  2019).  In   that  Chapter,  I   have  explained,   in   great  detail,  how  this  policy  was determined   through   a  party  referendum which  was  held  in 1993;  just   before  the  transition  to  the  multi-party  parliament  in  1995.                                                                                               
            The   referendum   had  been   necessitated  by  the  adoption  by  the  one-party   Parliament,  of  a  resolution  demanding  the  establishment  of  a  separate  government  for  Tanzania  Mainland,  which  would  have  resulted   in  a  three-government  structure  of  the  Union.  That   resolution  was,  in   effect,   a  rebellion  against  the  said  party  policy.                                                           
                The  results of  the  said  referendum  were  that  61%  of  the  entire  CCM  membership  had  voted  in  favour  of  retaining  the  two-government  structure  of  the  Union.   These    referendum  results  imposed   an  obligation  on  members  of  that    Parliament  “to  go  back  to  the  drawing  board”  and  rescind  their   previous  resolution;  which  they  quickly  did.    
        Regarding  the  matter  of  private  candidates  in  elections.
This other   matter of  denying  the  right  to  independent  candidates  to  participate  in  elections,  is  also  a  carryover  from  the  policies  of  the  ruling  party,  that  was inadvertently  imported  into  the  country’s  constitution.  In  this  case  also,   there  is  no  valid  reason  for  denying  the  argument  (which  has  been  advanced  by  many  concerned  stakeholders),  that  this  provision  is  a  breach  of  the  ‘freedom  of  association’  which  is  guaranteed  to  every  citizen  by  the  constitution  of  the  United  Republic.  
         And,  similarly,   as  has  also   been argued  by  the  concerned    stakeholders,   there  is  no  cogent  reason  for  denying  the  electors  their  right  to  vote  “for  a  person  of  integrity   whom  they  know  well,  in  preference  to  voting   for  a  party  candidate   simply  on  the  basis  of  a  party   programme  that  is  skillfully   promoted  in  a   party  election   campaign”. Now,  the   crucial  question:   how   then,   should  we  proceed  from  here?  In  my   humble,  considered    opinion,  we  should  “throw  the  bucket  where  we  are”.                             
             The   expression   “throw  your  bucket  where you  are”   is  derived  from  the   story  of  a  cargo  ship,  which   reportedly   had  been  stranded  for  many  days   somewhere  in  the  Atlantic  Ocean;   but  the  captain  did  not  know  exactly  where  they  were.   So,  he   sent  a  desperate  signal  to  the  ship  owners,   requesting  an  urgent   supply  of  drinking  water  for  the  crew.   The   reply   came swiftly:   “throw  your  bucket  where  you  are”. What   this  meant  was  that   the  stranded   ship  was  actually  in  the  precise  location  where  the  Amazon   river  enters  the  Ocean;  so  they  were  actually   in  the  middle  of  fresh  water  from  that  river.   
This   analogy  seems  to  me  to  be  relevant,  and   applicable,  to  the  situation  in  which   we  currently  are,  regarding   the  matter  or  matter  of  resuming  our  constitutional  review  process.                        It  is  my  humble  submission,  that  we   should   ‘throw  the bucket  where  we   currently  are”; by  taking  stock  of  all  the  past  endeavours  in  this  connection,  and  adding  thereto  any   new  ideas  that  may  seem  appropriate   in  the  present  circumstances.                                                              
        Furthermore,    considering   the   fact   that   there  are  those  established   ‘constitutional  principles’  (mentioned  above)  that  are  applicable  to  every   democratic   constitution;   it  is  presumed  that  these  will  need  no  revision.   And   since   these   principles   are  already  incorporated  in  the  current  constitution  (disregarding the  failings  and  the  malpractices  mentioned  above);   the  current  situation    seems  to  be    the  most  appropriate   starting  point   for  the  resumption  of  our  constitutional  review  process.  We  should  first   rectify  the  past   malpractices,  and  then   proceed  to  identify  and  incorporate   any  new  ideas. 
piomsekwa@gmail.com /0754767576.
Source: Cde Msekwa

Thursday, 12 January 2023

Who Actually Overthrew Mugabe?

History is crucial for every nation. To know its future, it must know its past. That’s where the centrality of history radiates. Today, I’ll briefly interrogate the coup that unseated Robert Mugabe. In 2017, Zimbabwe, for the second time of its choppy antiquity, evidenced what, up until now, has never gotten a scientific definition. The first one’s when disgraced Amai employed bedroom tactics to topple the Jongwe who later was finished off by the Ngwena. 
        Therefore, what transpired in Zim for the second time in 2017’s called coup d’état per se. Some call it a soft coup. Others call it a Zimbabwean thing. To others, it remains undefined and undefinable. For me though, what transpired was a coup. Neither’s it soft nor hard. It’s a coup if we agree that coup means an act or omission of pulling down of the government by mounting another on its place regardless of who’s behind or whether the fallen government was elected democratically or installed militarily. At law, Coup is unconstitutional by nature. Thus, whoever carried it out’s breaking the constitution of the land regardless of if the one booted out did or replicated the same. The difference’s that what transpired in Zim at the material time’s a civicmilitary coup that involved politicians and military. No coup can make sense without its executor, which in many cases is the junta. To know what happened in Zim when Jongwe’s booted out, even though his age had already phased him out, we need to know who took over thereafter.
        As we ponder on the coup and its beneficiary, we need to look at who controlled and benefited or benefited whom, or who did what and got what considering the following realities:
        Two dramatis personae feature high in this coup, namely the then fired Vice President Emerson Mnangagwa and the then Commander of Zimbabwe Defence Forces, Constantino Chiwenga. Before booting Mugabe out, Chiwenga used to control Mugabe, his party, and regime. That’s why he easily scythed them out though not all if we consider the fact that the Lacoste fraction outfoxed and powdered the military, Mugabe, and his wife and snatched the power thereof.
         Although Chiwenga and the military controlled Mugabe, another person did too. This was none other than the first lady who exploited the bedroom politics to try to give presidency a shot to no avail. What would she do if the old codger had already become senile over a decade before? One thing that this disgraced and greedy lady didn’t see’s the fact that nobody’s ever executed such a scheme in Africa. Did she want to become a harbinger of a bedroom coup or what? Again, with her measly education, despite being dubiously awarded a fake PhD, how could she skillfully and successfully execute such a complex scheme?
        By controlling Mugabe, his party, and regime, the army controlled everybody Zim underhandedly. If Chiwenga really controlled everything including the army to which he’s its top, how did he end up being controlled after the coup? This brings us to who actually deposed Mugabe between Mnangagwa, current boss, and his shadow aka backup, Chiwenga.  
        Naturally, in autocratic and crooked countries, politicians depend on the army to rule not vice versa. The two are like yin and yang though the latter brandish much more power than the former.  If this is the case, should we think that the duo consists of nothing but a puppet and a puppeteer? Whom depends on the mercy of who, why and for how long? Who gained and who lost in this convoluted coup? Who outsmarted whom and why?
        The questions above are crucial, especially at the moment Zims are preparing themselves for the coming general elections. Such questions must be correctly answered with the aim of freeing Zim from a kit and caboodle of hangers-on that have held it at ransom. 
        Zims need to know who toppled their government so that they can do in him or her. For, if they’d so, chances for the ongoing sanctions against it might be lifted. Zims need to execute a scheme that’ll free them including their sellouts in the upper echelons of power and the beneficiaries of the coup in question. 
        Methinks Zim needs probable, provable, and reliable persons but not coup makers. Their stint in offices hasn’t helped Zims out of the imbroglio, miseries, and manmade stinking penury. Who’d like such barracudas and washouts in the highest office of the land? Again, who benefited from the coup that saw the Jongwe being eaten by Ngwena?
Source: Zimbabwe Independent today.

Tuesday, 10 January 2023

AFRICA AND GMOS


 

Remembering the Times of Disgraced, Gucci Grace

Wherever you’re after losing big, I’m pretty sure; you’ll read this piece offered pro bono as a counsel to likeminded first ladies.  I know, you know. Your hubby Bob turned Zim into his private estate for many years supported by the army. Again, as they days went by, his magic wand waned. Things became worse after you manipulated him and staged a bedroom coup by greedily and blindly plotting his fall. You took advantage of his senescence without knowing that things have drastically changed. Yours was power, power only. Thanks to your greed, myopia, and ignorance, you only saw one side of the coin. Power deceptively clambered onto your puny pâté that you’d turn Zimbabwe into Graceland or Greedland after taking over from kaput Bob. What a fatal and sacrilegious mistake!
            Thanks to your ignorance and greed, you misjudged power dynamics, especially the centrality of the military and war veterans. You naively forgot; the power yum-yum you’re enjoying was the product of the blood and sweat of the duo above. Instead of making do with them by averting power hunger, you myopically thought power was like a sybaritic game you used to play in bed. Power’s so sophisticated, especially for a person of your caliber with only infinitesimal and pitiable knowhow.
Now, your husband’s no more and the game is long gone and up. What of you who’s almost a half of his age? What are you into and up to currently? Guess what. You’ve a crucial role to play in the historicity of Zim? Upshoot? You’ll help us to discourage those planning to replicate your tricks to launch bedroom coups. Did you know? I can assure you, my sister. Though Bob’s and your power is a bygone now, he wasn’t the first to be helped to take a rest. It once happened in Tunisia. Habib Bourguiba’s relieved of power to free him from power brokers who’d, like yourself, hijacked him in 1987. He’s then almost ten years younger than your husband. Importantly, I know. Your husband survived many big waves to end up being brought down by an illiterate lady simply because he shared bed with you!
        Disgraced, sorry, Grace, forgive me. You’re fully involved in bedroom politics. To show who truly you’re, Zimbabwe and the world in general jubilated when the Zimbabwe Armed Forces averted the country the shame you enacted although it created another. It made no sense for Dalilah to sit on the highest sit of power in the land simply because she dreamt about being president not to mention using her body to do so. Essentially, this must be a lesson to other myopic dictators whose wives are operating them like puppeteers.
        Disgraced, sorry, Grace, you violated Robert and Zimbabwe. Can you say mea culpa, mea culpa and apologise?  You brought shame to African women who are renowned for being patient and supportive to their husbands. Your greed and myopia are now eating you up. If I were you, I’d have spent much time either upgrading my education or helping poor women in the land? Instead, you spent much time and money on power hunting to end up being haunted by power not to mention being hunted like an antelope. Believe ye my sister. Zim’ll never let you go scot-free. It’d badly want you to be brought to book for the sacrilege you committed. It’d like to see you in the same position former Ivorian first lady Simone Gbagbo once was in after misleading her husband the same way you besmirched Bob.
        Disgraced, sorry, Grace did you know? God’s nowadays faster in repaying than before? The sage’s it that whatever you do, payments or rewards are here on earth. Absolutely, absolute power corrupts absolutely the sage has it. After being married to Bob––––after betraying and divorcing your hubby––––you forgot your humble past. You self-appointed a power behind the throne.  Had you been educated, maybe, you’d have studied or remembered the history of Simone Gbagbo if not that of Elena Ceausescu nee Lenuța Petrescu former Romania first lady who bungled and corrupted her husband so as to start off a tragedy that saw them deposed and summarily killed.
        Now, provided that the fall of your husband is mainly associated with your power lust, I’m pretty sure. In post-Bob era, Zimbabweans are likely to forgive him for his other sins, especially if they remember how he fought for and brought independence to Zim and bungled it because of you.  As for you, I don’t know if they’ll stomach forgiveness provided that many flaws you committed resulted from evil intention of grabbing power and keeping on abuse and misusing it at their detriment.
Finally, Disgraced, Greed, sorry, Grace, brace yourself to answer for millions of bucks you robbed and squandered at the time Zimbabweans were dying of hunger, preventable and curable diseases.
Wait Grace wait
Never stop to wait
  Wait for justice to be served
Yep, wait for the reward
Yep, reward for your greed
What a lesson!
Source: Zimbabwe Independent today.

Monday, 9 January 2023

East Africa Community must safeguard DRC for its own good

East African leaders must tap the potential of the DRC to thrive
 | I recently wrote a piece on what to do to avoid inter-member conflicts in the new East African Community (EAC). Sadly, nobody’s interested in it. It died an unnatural death. However, I still read about a simmering conflict between Kinshasa and Kigali over the M23, a rebel group based in the DRC, which’s set two EAC members against each other. The DRC openly accuses Rwanda of supporting the M23.
        It is a wee shell-shocking to know that the EAC myopically seems to allow the destabilisation of the giant among its members. The DRC has much more to offer to the EAC than receive. Just imagine what a country of 2,345,409 km2 with the population of approx. 90 million inhabitants can offer to the regional body whose size is 2,467,202 km2. and population of approx. 184 million inhabitants.
        Considering its humungous landmass, untapped resources, many economic opportunities, and significance not to mention its strategic location among others, the DRC isn’t only vital but also a lifeline for the region’s development.
        The roles it’ll play in the EAC aren’t for itself but also for the entire East African region in general. Importantly, the DRC has more to offer when it comes to land and resources than the members of EAC put together. Therefore, whoever wishes the EAC to rise and shine, must consider DRC’s security and tranquility.
        For, DRC’s non-EAC’s member neighbours such as Cameroon, the Central African Republic (CAR) and the Republic of Congo have no plan to form any economic community or make use of its humungous resources. If they’d, they’d easily lure it into their fold because of the cultural, colonial, linguistic closeness they share. Had they been smart, they’d have already snatched this opportunity.

News that DRC is complaining about being sabotaged needs to be handled urgently. 

        The lack of a solution to this problem doesn’t augur well for those who wish to see the EAC become a force to reckon with not only in the region but also in the continent. How can such a player been treated with disdain while its membership to the EAC is likely to spur all goals the community has ever aspired to achieve? How come such a giant is ignored even when it complains about being violated?  Is there any dirty politics being played for the peril of the EAC? What’s amiss here? Who needs another regardless of our land mass size? This column seeks, inter alia, to answer these questions.
Firstly, the fact that DRC is the newest member means it needs to be treated like a baby.
What is it about the DRC?
Secondly, the DRC has a chunk of population of over 80 million that can add up to the market regionally. Market power is something everybody wants.
        Thirdly, the DRC’s has humungous source of resources of value particularly fertile and virgin land, minerals, timber, lakes, and rivers.
        Fourthly, the DRC has predictable weather when it comes to farming, which factor top up to its natural significance.
        Fifthly, the DRC’s such a mammoth landmass equal to the size of the EAC whose population compared to its landmass is sparser than the EAC, which can help to combat land scarcity shall the EAC decide to unite and form a single country.
        Tanzania with the landmass bigger than both original founder of EAC put together, for instance, used to drag its feet for fear of allowing other tiny countries without land or resources like it comparably to help themselves on its abundant resources and massive land. If ‘one nation’ is actualised, Tanzania won’t shudder or waver to fully embrace the community. It can now hang its hat to the community with confidence that now things will work in the favour of everybody.
        Sixthly, some academics posit that the DRC suffers from resource curse whose hex can be thwarted by a practical unification of the EAC.  Burundi is a very good example. When it joined the EAC, its civil wars lessened and later the country became politically stable as it’s been ever since. If the EAC replicates the same to South Sudan and the DRC, chances are that the region will become another political and economic powerhouse to reckon with. Thus, there are no logical reasons of failing to solve instability the DRC faces.
        Finally, the this disconnected giant cannot be calmed in the absence of peace and security. Despite having all goodies mentioned above, the DRC has one of the most dilapidated and poor infrastructure that needs to be titivated and established where there’s none. How can the infrastructure be improved without peace and security?
        Although the DRC is on the Atlantic Ocean, it as good as a landlocked country due to the fact that its coast isn’t developed.

The EAC has all reasons to secure the DRC. For, if the EAC secures the DRC, apart from doing a right thing towards the reunification of Africa, it’ll also have actualised having a pool of critical assets for development namely, land, resource and manpower not to mention the market thereof.
Source: Independent (Uganda).

Saturday, 7 January 2023

Whataboutism and UDA impunity

 UDA has some smart and intelligent people such as Dr David Ndii, although it still beats me how he made that den of cartels his political home.Truth be told, a large number of UDA honchos couldn’t even pass a liberal application of Chapter Six of the Constitution.

UDA is infested with many senior – and wealthy – know-nothings. The vast majority of them can’t credibly explain to any credible court, or ethical national forum how, where and when they acquired their wealth. If the  word impunity had a portrait, the party would perfectly fit it. That’s why the argument about the rule of law is wrapped in “whataboutism”. If you point a finger at them, they point a longer one.
Whataboutism is a logical fallacy which is used as a propaganda technique by those whose conscience isn’t clear or those who have malign objectives. The textbook use of whataboutism is responding to an argument, or question, with a snarky retort, or a critical counter-question. Such a response is usually in the form of a counter-accusation.
    For example, say I ask you why your father was a thief. In a whataboutism retort, you would ask me why my mother was a more notorious thief. The response is an attempt to quash an incriminating truth, kill an unfavourable conversation, or end a line of questioning that’s unwinnable. Whataboutism is a device for the wicked and those who have the stuff to hide.
I’ve gone to great lengths to elucidate whataboutism because it’s become the key tool of propaganda employed by the UDA regime. Initially, I thought it was simply a tactic of the boy who cried wolf. But I have now come to believe that it’s a political strategy to misdirect, misinform and flummox a hapless public.
It’s taken from deep in the arsenal of denialism. Its purpose is to blind the public from the administration’s many failures and its inability to fulfil its pie-in-the-sky campaign promises. The people were hoodwinked, and the only way you can keep them from realising they have been had is to hoodwink them even more. As they say, a sucker is born every second. 
If you recall the 2022 campaigns, UDA’s leader William Ruto built his main pitch on two pillars. The first was to blame the “Handshake” between Jubilee’s Uhuru Kenyatta and ODM’s Raila Odinga. He cunningly, if falsely, hung bad policy on them. Never mind that he was numero dos in government for a smacking 10 years. 
God’s messenger 
In the second pillar, Mr Ruto promised heaven on earth to his gullible supporters. Often, he sounded like God’s messenger to the vulnerable. But remember the biblical admonition in Psalms 12: 2-3 about those who “speak and deceive in forked tongues”. Remember UDA’s 100-day report returned blanks, or failed promises. UDA’s number two, Rigathi Gachagua, was no different. He still cries the loudest.
The two top whataboutism kings are Mr Ruto and Mr Gachagua. All the others below – be they MPs, ministers, or their subordinates – have followed suit. Every time a common citizen or a critic from Azimio asks a bona fide question, either Mr Ruto, or Mr Gachagua, and increasingly other UDA factotums like Mr Musalia Mudavadi, or Mr Aden Duale, stand up as though on cue. Usually, they will blame either Mr Kenyatta or Mr Odinga for an obscure wrong, or something irrelevant. What’s important is they never answer the question at hand, or pretend to do so. They never see the logs in their own eyes. Instead, they emote righteous anger and fulminate against their critics. 
The most poignant is Mr Gachagua. Before the elections, Mr Gachagua was prosecuted by the Director of Public Prosecutions over unexplained wealth. The High Court found Sh202 million belonging to Mr Gachagua were proceeds of crime. The Asset Recovery Agency (ARA) seized the cash. 
Now, the ARA has asked the Court of Appeal to set aside the High Court ruling based on “new” evidence to return Mr Gachagua’s money. Excuse me, do I look like I live in Mars? This stinks to the high heavens. 
"Vanishing sins"
It seems all you have to do is be in UDA and your sins vanish into thin air. If you raise this question now, “whataboutists” spring up and list all of Mr Kenyatta’s “sins”. 
So far, virtually all UDA politicians and officials who had been charged, or those whose assets had been seized during the Kenyatta state, are now being let go, or their assets returned. People with blatantly corrupt or criminal records have been appointed by Mr Ruto to the most senior positions in the country.
The government is overloaded with appointees from two communities. Inclusion is only a rumour. And yet when you ask these questions, even to those UDA adherents who are excluded, you get an “whataboutism” retort. Has Kenya become the theatre of the absurd? Who are we? Who have we become? Do we even recognise ourselves anymore?
Makau Mutua is SUNY Distinguished Professor and Margaret W. Wong Professor at Buffalo Law School, The State University of New York. @makaumutua.
Source: Sunday Nation tomorrow.

Friday, 6 January 2023

What Does Patriotism Mean to Zimbabwe and Zimbabweans?

 

I read somewhere that President Emerson Mnangagwa’s seconding a bill that’ll heavily and undeservedly, of course, chastise any Zimbabwean that’ll tarnish the image of the nation. The bill stipulates “any citizen or permanent resident of Zimbabwe (hereinafter in this section called “the accused”) who, within or outside Zimbabwe actively partakes… in any meeting whose object the accused knows or has reasonable grounds for believing involves….military or other armed intervention in Zimbabwe…subverting, upsetting, overthrowing or overturning the constitutional government in Zimbabwe; shall be guilty of willfully damaging the sovereignty and national interest of Zimbabwe and liable to- (i) the same penalties as for treason, in a case referred to in paragraph (a); or (ii) the same penalties as for subverting constitutional government.”

            If anything, this law aims at nothing but to have down on any person ideated as an enemy of the states. By looking at how the law’s verbalized, even if your enemy lies to the authority that you’re meeting or intending to topple the government, you’ll be arrested. The so-called bill’s so gossipy since much of the elements are but mere rumours. For example, what does ‘upsetting or overturning’ the national constitution’ mean while the two terms mean the same? What does it mean if any person–––unsatisfied with it–––has legal power to demand that it be amended or changed?  Isn’t this upsetting the same?  Why using vague terms in writing a bill if there isn’t something fishy?

            Before rummaging into the matter, let’s define what patriotism means. The concept of patriotism or patria (Greek) or one’s native country or homeland, or male power over family evolved over 2,000 years ago in Europe.  The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (2020) defines it as “love of one’s country, identification with it, and special concern for its well-being and that of compatriots.” Does Mnangagwa practically love his country? How if he toppled an elected government? How if he’s never had any concern for the well-being of his compatriots in the opposition? How if corruption and selfishness have always been rife in his regime? How if Mnangagwa’s seconding the bill that aims to bully and strong-arm a big section of Zimbabweans to crouch before his narrow but not national gains?

Some reporters called this law draconic. Nay. It’s more than that. It’s purely archaic, colonial, and obnoxious. If anything, this is nothing but puerile excuse if not the sign that desperados have run out of gas if not road. Government lawyers who advised it to bring such a deplorable bill–––that aims to enact bad laws–––seem to not know the history of Zimbabwe, especially the 2017. How did Mnangagwa get in power and where did he come from? He met with his conspirators in South Africa and toppled Mugabe. He did exactly the same he’s now diabolising. Swahili sage’s that the simian doesn’t see its nates. Therefore, it laughs those of other simians. In Latin, you can call this holier than thou idiocy. Mnangagwa must say mea culpa, mea culpa, as he guiltily lashes his chest, rescind the bill and apologise to the Zimbabweans.

  In law, what Mnangagwa did wasn’t only traitorous by all laws and standards since two elements of criminal liabilities, namely actus reus (act or omission) and mens rea (malice aforethought or intention to commit an offence) are openly demonstrably present. How d’you tie Mnangagwa to his bill and find him criminally liable? He conspired with others, met them in South Africa, and keeled an elected government. Was that a patriotic act, if we consider the fact that if Zimbabweans didn’t omit to stop this treason since the overthrower and his dupe were bow-wows, Mnangagwa’s treasonable acts would have sent Zimbabwe tumbling down due to the mayhem that’d have ensured thereof.

Let me look at this law that’s specifically aimed at bullying and intimidating Zimbabweans from hold the regime accountable. Are Zimbabwean rulers patriotic in the first place? How if tons of ignominies are the only things that define them. Let’s examine them clinically. Al Jazeera (Dec. 12, 2022) reports as thus “the US Treasury Department accused Emmerson Mnangagwa Jr of ties to sanctioned businessman Kudakwashe Tagwirei.” All Zimbabweans know what this scandal entrails in details. True patriots never rape juveniles or the economies of their country. Are the accused persons above patriots? Like father like son the sage has it. The proposed law is not only bad but also evil.

Source: Independent Zimbabwe today.

Tuesday, 3 January 2023

Rais Samia Jifunze kwa Raila Odinga

 

Alipotangaza nia ya kugombea Urais nchini Kenya na baadae kugombea, Kiongozi wa upinzani nchini humo, Raila Odinga alipewa kila aina ya sifa kiasi cha kulewa, kujisahau, na kuishia kushindwa kwenye uchaguzi tata wa mwezi Septemba 2022. Wengi hawakuamini kama Odinga angebwagwa na mwanagezi wake wa siasa aliyekuwa akikabiliwa na tuhuma lukuki za ufisadi, unyakuzi ardhi, na nyingine nyingi mbali na kuzungukwa na watu wasio na udhu kama mgombea mwenza ambaye sasa ni naibu wa Rais.
            Hivi karibuni, kwenye vikao vilivyopita vya Chama Cha Mapinduzi (CCM) vilivyokumbwa na tuhuma nyingi za rushwa, wasaka ngawira wengi walimmwagia sifa kedekede Mheshimiwa Rais Samia Suluhu Hassan. Japo rushwa haimo ndani ya CCM bali nchi nzima, kwa chama tawala, hii ni aibu na ushahidi kuwa kinahitaji kufanya marekebisho makubwa hasa kwa upande wa maadili. Leo safu hii itagusia namna makada wengi wa CCM wanavyohanikiza kuwa Mheshimiwa Rais Samia anatosha kuwa mgombea wake wa 2025. Si vibaya kumpenda Mwenyekiti wao na Rais wa nchi. Hata hivyo, mbona wanaanza siasa za uchaguzi ujao wakati haujafika kisheria? Mbona wanakinzana na msimamo wa Mwenyekiti kuwa sasa ni wakati wa kufanya kazi na si siasa hasa ikizingatiwa kuwa uchaguzi uliisha mwaka juzi?
            Katika kuwasikiliza makada wengi wa CCM, wengi wao wakiwa ni wastaafu, hawajengi hoja zenye mashiko wala kuelezea ni kwanini Samia pekee. Kwanini hawajui kuwa, kumpitisha––––hata kama anapendwa sana, jambo ambalo halina ubishi–––bila kufanya uchaguzi wa ndani ya chama si sahihi na ni kinyume na demokrasia ambayo, kimsingi, inapaswa kuanzia ndani ya chama? Kimsingi, wanaomshauri na kumpotosha Mheshimiwa Samia kugombea Urais kwa kuwazuia wanachama wengine hawamsaidii. Kwa anavyokubalika, sioni kama anahitaji kufanya au kufanyiwa hivyo.
            Si vibaya kusema wazi: wengi wa makada wakongwe wanaomshauri awe dikteta ndani ya chama wanamtakia mema. Kinachowasukuma ni matumbo yao zaidi ya mapenzi ya chama, kwa Samia, na hata taifa. Wanaonyesha kuwa hawakujifunza tokana na utawala wa chama kimoja ambao uliondolewa na wakubwa zetu baada ya kuwa chaka la uimla na ufisadi.
            Tukirejea kwa Odinga, licha ya kuwa mwanasiasa mkongwe, mkomavu, mwenye mbinu na anayependwa, aliungwa mkono na utawala uliopita wa Uhuru Kenyatta bila mafanikio. Kimsingi, Odinga alihadaika na sifa za kinafiki na kigeugeu cha waliokuwa wakimwimbia mapambio maarufu akiwa ni Katibu Mkuu wa Chama cha Wafanyakazi cha Kenya (COTU), Francis Atwoli aliyesikika kabla na wakati wa kampeni akisema kuwa William Ruto asingechaguliwa wala kushinda. Atwoli alikaririwa mara nyingi akimsifia Odinga kuwa hapakuwa na mwanasiasa nchini Kenya ambaye angeweza kumshinda.
            Kuonyesha unafiki wa waimba mapambio, Odinga alipoangushwa kwenye uchaguzi uliogubikwa na shutuma za wizi wa kura, Atwoli sasa anamwimbia Ruto mapambio akimkosoa vibaya Odinga. Hadi tunaandika, wapo vigogo wengi waliokuwa wakimwamisha Odinga kinafiki kuwa angeshinda kirahisi waliokwishamgeuka na kumkimbia. Kundi hili linahusisha aliyekuwa Waziri wa Mambo ya Ndani Daktari Francis Matiang’i, Gavana wa zamani wa Meru Kiraitu Murungi, na wengine wengi wakiwamo waliogombea ubunge kwa tiketi ya Chama chake cha Orange Democratic Movement (ODM). Hawa ni makahaba wa kisiasa au political prostitutes waliojazana duniani.
            Uzoefu toka Kenya umeonyesha kuwa wapo wanasiasa wengi wachumia tumbo na wasasi wa ngawira wanaojifanya kumpenda kiongozi fulani wakitegemea ashinde. Anaposhindwa, humgeuka na kumkimbia wengine tena wakigeuka maadui zake wakubwa. Hata Tanzania tunao wachumia tumbo kama hawa waliowahi kumzunguka Hayati John Magufuli na kuishia kumgeuka hata wengine kumsimanga. Bahati mbaya, baadhi yao wamerudishwa ima  chamani au serikalini bila kuchelea tabia yao ya kuunga mkono yeyote ilimradi wafanikishe miradi yao ya kusaka ulaji au kulinda biashara zao. 
            Japo Rais Samia hana mpinzani wa kuweza kumshinda sasa tokana na upinzani nchini kuwa goigoi na uliosambaratika, kuna haja ya kuangalia waliomzunguka. Wanaweza wasimkimbie tokana na mfumo mzima wa Tanzania kuwa wa kikale uliowezesha CCM kushinda chaguzi zote. Bado wachumia tumbo hawa wenye sifa ya kujikomba na kujipendekeza, wanaweza kumchafulia jina lake kwa kujiingiza kwenye biashara haramu kama vile ya usafirishaji nyara za taifa, ufisadi, mihadarati, mengine kama hayo, Umma hausemi japo unawajua tena kwa majina.
            Hivi karibuni kumefumka kashfa ya bonde la Ihefu inayohusisha familia 12 za vigogo waliochefusha maji na kuathiri mazingira vibaya sana. Je Rais atawachukulia hatua gani? Je atakubali watajwe na kushughulikiwa sawa na wahujumu uchumi wengine? Kadhia hii inaweza kuonyesha ni kwanini baadhi ya makada wa sasa na wastaafu wanajitahidi kuhanikiza kumpigia debe Samia hata kabla ya uchaguzi. Si kwamba wanaipenda CCM au Tanzania. Hasha. Wanachopenda ni matumbo yao. Na hakuna kingine.
            Tumalizie kwa kumtaka Rais Samia na wanandani wake wa karibu kupiga darubini na kuwabaini vyura wengi wanaopiga makelele ya kumpigia kampeni kabla ya wakati mbali na kumsifia kwa kila jambo bila kumkosoa utadhani yeye ni malaika asiyekosea. Tumeyaona haya wakati wa Hayati Magufuli na kwenye kadhia ya kushindwa kwa Odinga. Ni suala la kujifunza tu tokana na uzoefu wa wengine na pengine.
Chanzo: Raia Mwema kesho.

Monday, 2 January 2023

Mwangaza only guilty of absurdity

I have watched with dismay the saga of Meru Governor Kawira Mwangaza. It’s a painful spectacle to behold. Embarrassing – like walking in on your aunt taking a shower. Cringe-worthy – like realising your fly is open in public. But none of these incidents is illegal unless you left your fly open as an act of nudity and public lewdness.  From what I can see, Ms Mwangaza is guilty of absurdity, but not a single impeachable offence. Low political, or emotional, intelligence isn’t a violation of the 2010 Constitution for the holder of any political office. Let’s remember the device of impeachment is a nuclear option that should only be aimed at politicians the public is convinced must be destroyed.

        When you go to the shooting range, the first thing the instructor tells you is that you must never aim the gun at anyone, or anything, unless you intend to destroy it. That’s true of impeachment.  A governor of a county under the 2010 Constitution is a mini-potentate, a pretend president of a mini-republic. But I say this only half-jokingly. The sovereignty of the county citizens who elect a governor isn’t a futile wish.

        It’s a mandate of the people that must be treated as sacrosanct unless it can be shown that the governor has breached that trust in fundamental ways. Even where an impeachable offence has been committed, the Senate must ask whether it’s grave enough for removal.

Political sobriety

        I am not a fan of certain aspects of devolution. One of them is the overabundance of members of county assemblies (MCAs). I get the notion of the county assembly and the critical role of grassroots oversight and legislation. It’s key to devolution.  But in a fledgling poor country like Kenya, MCAs must temper their exuberance with political sobriety. MCAs mustn’t act like drunken children who have been handed an AK-47. You know what would happen if you mix that cocktail. If MCAs don’t tame their appetite for money and power – and hew closely to the intention of the framers – we may have to revisit their purpose and utility. Overreaching, or throwing temper tantrums like little children, isn’t in their job description. 

        From what I have seen, Meru MCAs don’t like Ms Mwangaza’s “singing” husband, or that he sits in on some official meetings, and has been “allocated” the role of a “goodwill ambassador” by his wife. The MCAs should stop being jealous and get over it. I bet $1,000 that if the roles were reversed, the MCAs would find the antics of the female spouse amusing, not impeachable. Would I rather the singing husband wasn’t ubiquitous? Yes. But really what harm has he done? I think the MCAs don’t like the appearance of a “co-governor.” But that’s not what he is. He’s just a comic. Let him be. If anything, the couple is guilty of violating misogynistic gender rules.I

         haven’t seen any iota of evidence among the charges levelled by the MCAs that would stand scrutiny. It’s all – well, hot air! The various allegations against her – nepotism, irregular policy statements, violation of the separation of powers, irregular appointments, incitement, bullying, vilification or humiliation of MCAs, the clergy, MPs, or the violation of finance laws – don’t hold any water.

        What the MCAs have done is throw the kitchen sink at her, or as they say, throw spaghetti at the wall and hope some of it sticks. The allegations are sensational but lack supporting evidence. Some of the other claims, such as bullying or vilifying leaders, are simply juvenile. These are schoolyard taunts that are simply contemptible. 

Political sense

        While it’s true the Meru governor and her husband are not politically savvy and lack political good manners, the MCAs are equally without political sense. An impeachment is a blunt object that is meant to smash an unruly politician who’s turned irredeemably rogue. Ms Mwangaza has been in office for only the proverbial two minutes. She has no track record, except putting her foot in her mouth every time she opens it. 

       Then she committed the sin of showing men the middle finger. I could’ve told her that male testosterone in conservative societies doesn’t like such acts of contempt from women. Most men believe women must listen to them, and do as they command. Ms Mwangaza doesn’t have time for such entitlements.  

      Finally, the Senate must set clear standards for impeachment, or county governments will become a joke. If we start impeaching governors for breaking wind in public, we shall destroy the integrity of devolution. The Senate must set a very high bar. It must reject attempts by MCAs to extort governors for a share of the loot.

            It’s true some governors must be impeached for looting and abuse of office. But let’s not treat impeachment like a walk in the park. Impeaching a governor barely three months after an election smells fishy. Let’s give Governor Mwangaza more time to show what she can do. Hopefully, she will become wiser.

Makau Mutua is SUNY Distinguished Professor and Margaret W. Wong Professor at Buffalo Law School, The State University of New York. @makaumutua

Source: Sunday Nation yesterday

Friday, 30 December 2022

RIP GOAT PELE

Edson Arantes do Nascimento aka Pele (23 October 1940-29 December 2022).
The world will remember you as on of GOATs that left an indelible mark on football. 
RIP LEGEND

Wednesday, 28 December 2022

Open letter to African rulers

 

MNANGAGWA
DEAR African rulers,
I recently wrote a letter to President Joe Biden. I’m waiting for his response. As I do so, allow me to touch base with you. Every year, your masters new and old treat you to pageant and hoo-has full of empty promises and photo-ops in their capitals. We see you in Beijing, Bombay, Tokyo, Washington even Istanbul dressing yourselves down. You are always treated or rather maltreated like class eavesdropper by the head teachers.
            I’ve a questions for you: “Have you ever sat aside and seen how mortifying and exploiting such dress downs and kowtows are? Why don’t we see Asian or even South American leaders being displayed and harangued like acolytes? What lesson do you get from such obloquies that have never emancipated your countries even yourselves economically? Do you need to be lectured about your amour-propre [self-love] not to mention your countries that you seem to vend year-in-year out?”
        I recently watched with consternation as you were paraded in Washington where your head teacher, the US President had not time to meet with you severally, lecturing you about the “importance” of Africa. Before long, the President of Ukraine, a country equivalent to 1/50 of Africa, a young man of the age of your children, being accorded a very resound reception even when some of you were still in the city for browsing while your spouses were shopping for stuffs and non-governmental organisations. Ukraine’s President was entertained in the White House on top of addressing United States House of Representatives. Don’t tell me that it is because of the war. Doesn’t Africa have wars in the Central Africa Republic, Democratic Republic of Congo, South Sudan, Somalia, and other places? Why didn’t you ask for the permission to address the congress?
            Another thing that shows you how colonial power trifles with you is the money the US has promised on those past two occasions. Whereas you’re promised US$55 billion equivalent to US$1 billion each if you divide evenly — Ukraine, apart from having already received over US$68 billion (CSIS, December 18, 2022) from the US, was promised US$45 billion (CNBC, December 24, 2022), which totals over US$100 billion approximately twice as much in one year.
Ask yourselves — how long will it take for you to get that US$55 billion, which wasn’t specified if it were aid or investment or whatever? Three years. (Reuters, December 12, 2022).
            Seeing that, I asked myself if you really respect yourselves.
How did you feel? Think about it a wee bit even without saying anything.
From such painful realisation, I’m, therefore, here to tell you point blank.
What you’re doing is counterproductive for Africa, a shame, and a sellout.
If you want to be either taken seriously or respected, you must do so for yourselves and your citizens first.
        Why have you failed and refused to learn from your colonial past that you seem to be at home with. Your deplorable and self-degrading behaviour is repellent not only for your countries but also for every black person including those the diaspora. Naturally, business dictates that he or she who needs anything from the market, or the sources must go for it.
            For you, it is sadly the opposite. All countries that need and depend on your vast resources of value summon you and tell you what they want and how to get it.
In other words, they set the terms instead you doing it or negotiating the deals.
From such a blind and tapered rationale, Africa’s always received a raw deal.
When this happens, you start complaining that Africa is treated unfairly. Who causes that if not you? How can you avoid that if you too don’t treat yourself decently and fairly? From my experience, even if you go to those capitals begging and pleading, surely, you’ll never make any headway. Whatever you do isn’t up to snuff. Do you know that the freebees in the name of aid you receive are but a fraction of what your corruption, negligence and selfishness cause?
            What you’ve been and are doing is psychotic, namely, practicising a repetitive stunt and expecting different results. Therefore, kindly, please, stop this hang-up. Your resources — if wisely managed and used — are likely to make Africa richer than those you pointlessly depend on for handouts. Imagine.
How Africa maintained its self-worth and civilisation for millions of years before being colonised and thereby its civilisation felled and made a laughing stock that it currently is.
        In a nutshell, let me be above-board to you and myself. Africa’s problems are the lack of sane management, dignified leadership, use of its resources and use of just common sense among others. Here’s where Africa’s poverty emanates and lies. That’s why I refer to you as rulers but not leaders. You rule instead of leading.
If you morphe yourselves into leaders, you’ll practically fight corruption, extravagance, laziness and above all, abhor dependence while your countries sit on awe-inspiring resources of value that the entire world needs and can’t do without.

Start becoming leaders. Doing, so, will help you to value yourselves, your people and serve them into instead of turning them your servants for your narrow interests.
Source: Standard Zimbabwe yesterday

Sunday, 25 December 2022

Why Kenya is limping into 2023


There are some years on the Julian calendar that you simply want buried and forgotten. One such year is Anno Domini 2022, which was decidedly annus horribilis, a year of disaster and misfortune for Kenya. Everything that could go wrong went horribly wrong.
        Unless Kenya changes course, historians will think of Kenya into distinct chasms – the pre-2022 Kenya and the post-2022 Kenya. But that’s not how 2022 started. In fact, 2022 was supposed to be the Year of Hope for Kenya when the country’s most important democrat – Azimio’s Raila Odinga – was going to ascend to power. However, every hope was dashed by the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) and then Kenya’s Supreme Court. That’s why the country’s future may lie in ruins.
        I know there’s been a lot of Monday morning quarterbacks rushing to tell the story about “what happened”.  Many of these “insiders”, perhaps all, are just quislings who are either looking for relevance, or trying to catch the eye of the UDA regime. That’s because many Kenyans – elites and wannabe elites – cannot fathom themselves outside the state. Most will sell their own mothers down the river for less than the proverbial 20 pieces of silver. Those who are talking know nothing, or very little, and those who know aren’t talking. A time will come when insiders will speak.
        That time isn’t now. But there are some things that are obvious, even to those of feeble mind. Let’s dig deeper. I won’t revert to the matter of the IEBC and the Supreme Court about which I leave to the imagination of fellow citizens.
        First, let me say that I see a UDA regime that doesn’t believe it’s in power. If you listen to the top men, they speak as though the country is still in campaign mode. Of particular note is the person who is the country’s numero dos.
        That man doesn’t know what to say, how to say it, and when to say it. He seems to speak before engaging his noggin. Or more accurately, he allows his emotions to speak for him. In a way that’s good because his mind is a window into the regime’s insecurity.
        Second, I see an UDA regime that’s a tower of babel. The country’s numero dos is already working furiously to push his boss out of Mount Kenya. Ironically, that’s exactly what his boss tried to do to his superior.
            As they say, what goes around comes around. I see a huge kinetic collision between the regime’s two top leaders. A nuclear explosion awaits. Then beneath the two, there’s internecine warfare between ministers and other factotums.
What these struggles mean is that there’s a lot of heat, and no light. Instead of focusing on giving economic meaning to the life of the most vulnerable, policy incoherence is now the order of the day.  Ministers shoot from the hip in self-aggrandisement.
        Third, a panicked regime that lacks internal and external legitimacy is in a state of hyperactivity in all sectors. The guys and gals in the regime don’t seem to be sleeping. The regime believes any motion is good for the country.
            That’s how it plans to consolidate itself in power – by being omnipresent everywhere in Kenya and abroad. I see the regime’s top leaders “commissioning” and often re-commissioning on a daily basis projects that were completed by the previous government. This is motion without movement. In the meantime, the country’s most vital needs are unaddressed and the penury of the people continues to deepen. Everywhere in this country, even in UDA strongholds, I see Kenyans with long forlorn faces.
        Fourth, most ordinary Kenyans have been reduced to beggars. Now, I am shocked if the policeman, the security guard, the ordinary public servant, and of course relatives don’t beg for a few coins from me. It never used to be like this, even before the UDA regime. Something terrible has happened to our people. Recently, in one of the most high-end restaurants in Nairobi the head chef approached me as I dined with friends.
        He pleaded that I pay the bill under the table – off the books – so that he and his co-workers could split the loot. Our collective jaws dropped to the ground when I told my friends. I politely declined his offer to “cheat” on the establishment. The first 100 days of the UDA regime have been marked by failures that have shocked the conscience of the nation.
        A basic thematic outline has emerged. The key failures are the UDA regime’s disdain for the Constitution and laws of Kenya, the contempt for democracy and its institutions, the flagrant violation of Chapter Six of the Constitution on Leadership and Integrity, the regime’s intolerance and impunity, its proclivity to run roughshod over the rule of law, the rush to destroy the political opposition and quash dissent, the crude muzzling of Kenya’s vibrant press, and the blatant attempts to reverse the gains of devolution. We are limping into 2023.
Makau Mutua is SUNY Distinguished Professor and Margaret W. Wong Professor at Buffalo Law School, The State University of New York. @makaumutua
Source: Sunday Nation today.

Wednesday, 21 December 2022

Open letter to US President Joe Biden on Zimbabwe

Greetings
I recently evidenced US mission to charm and lure Africa after China showed ever-surging leverage in the continent that you’d to effectively and quickly counter and foil.
        Due to that, you’d take steps, mainly hoodwinking it by promising ‘boons and bonuses’ to keep Africa your conventional colony and natural material purveyor.  You told African rulers attending the US-African Leaders Summit in Washington DC recently that “Africa belongs at the table in every room, in every room where global challenges are being discussed and every institution where discussions are taking place” (cnn.com, Dec 15, 2022). Really? Seriously? Wow!
        Mr President, mark and watch my words. For conscious and traumatised Africans, your fake hutzpah, and honied libretti retraumatise. You used colonial referend to nicely but fortuitously describe how you view Africa and to deliver your intention (mens rea) of recolonising Africa.
        Whose table is Africa at? Is Africa a loaf of bread or a roasted chicken before colonial eyes, minds and psyche? Is it because Africa’s born, cloned, and disfigured at the table your ancestors congregated at the criminal and villainous Berlin conference (1884) that brutally and monstrously defiled on and disfigured Africa to what it currently it is, divided and partitioned and pathetic as a criminal gambit of weakening it in order to perpetually colonise and exploit it?
        For whoever cares about Africa, well intends, aims to decolonise and help Africa out of its colonial enacted futility, the language of the table traumatises Africa and Africans.
        Mr President, when you talk about every institution, what do you mean? Do you mean criminal and fake explorers, merchants, and missionaries who presided over the colonisation of Africa or the international superstructure and its tools such as the IMF, the UN, and the WB, inter alia, that abetted the colonisation and the mugging of Africa?
        To nicely hoodwink ever-begging and ever-dependent rulers despite sitting on humongous sources of resources of value, you promised to cough US$ billion. What a sweet deal if, indeed, you mean serious business.  Again, did you do this out of altruism or valuing Africa? Nay.
        The US woke up from its slumber after China made aggressive inroads in Africa. Mr President, did you think about your bait before offering it? Yeah. Do you think the US$55 billion is likely to entice and thereby quash the US$300 billion China promised last year by Diana Chen, China Africa Business Council head (VOA, February 2, 2022)? Who is fooling whom here?
        What new will you do for Africa if at all China’s already done everything from aid, building infrastructure, and corrupt deals if we face it? Do you know that China adapted and adopted your decoy to imbed itself in Africa? Mr President, I humbly present a case for Zimbabwe, a resilient country you wanted to go to the dogs to no avail after its people rose up against Mugabe to no avail.
        Though Zimbabwe, just like any country, has its internal issues, is it fair to hang it the way your country and the West in general have so brutally attempted by shunning it? I understand. Your clangour’s that Zimbabwe needs to embrace Western rule of law and the respect of human rights.
        Well, is Zimbabwe alone in this quagmire? Bad governance’s the creature of corruption, dictatorship and the absence of democracy among others like Western democracy is. Is Zimbabwe the only brutal and corrupt dictatorship the only corrupt in our colonial and corrupt world? What of your best stooges such as Egypt and Saudi Arabia among others? 
    Mr President, your country and the West wanted Zimbabwe to become a failed country. However, do you think if Zimbabwe becomes a failed government won’t the region and Africa in general be adversely affected? Ask South Africa that’s for a long time bore the burden of Zimbabwe’s colonial and man-made economic woes. Refer to how innocent Zimbabweans, for decades, have born the brunt.
        What humans’ human rights do you advocate? Why can’t you see that the botch or disintegration of Zimbabwe’s the failure of Africa you’re now spuriously enticing? You know it too well. You recently “exonerated” Venezuela’s sins after the West faced energy catch-22 when Russia went to war with Ukraine. Because of that, the West lost a big chunk of oil supply. Thus, you’d — out of double standards and necessity — to forgive Venezuela so that you can get oil supply.
Mr President, do you think Africa will advance economically without key players such as Zimbabwe whose contribution to world economy is bigger than your beloved Egypt? Let’s honestly and realistically reason together.
        Mr President, do you know that, if Zimbabwe’s scar and sin were its former President, Robert Mugabe, why’s it still shunned many years after his death? Your sanctions didn’t, and have never affected Mugabe, his family, you “targeted” though the truth’s different that you requited because white folks were chastened.
        Instead, your unfair sanctions have heinously affected innocuous babies, children, elderly people, pregnant women, and poor Zimbabweans. Was Mugabe real a real sin or racism is since Mugabe arrogated white farmers’ land that they also grabbed from blacks? Comparably, did Mugabe commit a bigger sacrilege than dictatorships in Egypt and Saudi Arabia still commit vis-à-vis gross violations of human rights? Is it because Zimbabwe is African and black?
        Mr President, please forgive me for bringing a racial nuance. I’m in Canada on your northerly border. I know too well how black people are systematically discriminated against in the West and the Americas including even those whom you torture like Venezuela that likewise replicate the same on blacks. I know too well what it’s to be black in a “white” world. I, hence, speak from real-world experience.
        In sum, Mr President, I rest my case praying that please, do justice for the haemorrhaging to death Zimbabwe and helpless Africa, lift the sanctions against Zimbabwe, which China has taken advantage of.
Sincerely yours,
Source: Independent Zimbabwe Yesterday.